- Pixel Fun
- Posts
- Pixel Fun #7: I have HomeView and iPhone Duo thoughts
Pixel Fun #7: I have HomeView and iPhone Duo thoughts
...and don't get me started on the PROLED MacBook Pro.

The new Tripod app on my iPhone Duo review unit
Thanks to an unprecedented run of new Apple announcements and releases, it’s been a busy few weeks. But busy is good, especially when there are new gadgets to enjoy. Or not, as the case may be.
I’m going to use this issue of Pixel Fun to dive into some of Apple’s biggest and most controversial releases, tease some future words, and no doubt ruffle a few feathers along the way.
Oh, and I have a new podcast app that you’re going to love. You won’t want to miss that!
The rundown:
📰 The Story:
We’ve seen three new iPhones unveiled and released, a refreshed iPad mini, new MacBook Pros, and a raft of new and updated Apple Home products break cover in the last couple of months. Some of those Home accessories still haven’t shipped, so there’s more to come.
I’m going to use Pixel Fun #7 to share some early thoughts on some of Apple’s September, October, and November releases and tease others. It shouldn’t surprise anyone that I have thoughts, but I think the content of them just might.
Let’s get the easy one out of the way first. I’ve been using a review loaner iPhone Air for the last year, and I’m a big fan. So when I was sent an iPhone 18 Pro Max, I already knew that it was going to be something of a culture shock — even as someone who used Pro Max iPhones exclusively before the Air arrived.
I was right. It’s big, and it’s heavy. But it’s also the best iPhone on the market right now. That might give you a hint as to my thoughts on another recent Apple release. I’m not going to get into details about my iPhone 18 Pro Max impressions here, though. You can read those in the AppleInsider review I wrote before the iPhone Duo went on sale at the end of October.
I’m also fortunate enough to have an iPhone Duo review unit in hand currently. But before I dive into that, I want to discuss an even more recent release: HomeView.
Apple HomeView
I’ll preface this with the fact that, for boring logistical reasons, I don’t have a HomeView to hand currently. That might change soon, but for now, I’m basing my thoughts on spending some time with one yesterday, talking to owners, and reading or watching other critics’ reviews.
That being said, I have concerns about HomeView, both about the state it shipped in and whether it will ever live up to both the hype and what I think it needs to be if it’s going to replace the millions of Echo Shows and Google Nest Hubs already in homes around the world.
I had high hopes for HomeView. I’ve always liked the idea of a smart display of some sort being the central focal point for a smart home. Apple’s ad for HomeView gave me hope that it could be exactly that. If you haven’t yet seen it, I suggest you watch it before reading further.
I suspect a lot of people watched that ad and saw their own family in the one Apple used to show HomeView’s capabilities. It’s a great ad, and it highlights how a smart display that hooks into the existing Apple ecosystem of devices and services could be huge for busy households.
Unfortunately, I’m not sure it’s indicative of the HomeView experience that shipped earlier this week.
I think I’m going to write something a little more in-depth for AppleInsider, so I’ll share that on Bluesky and Mastodon when it’s live. But the gist is pretty simple, and it gets to the heart of what a good smart display needs to do and do well. It needs to be useful for the whole family.
If it’s just going to be used by one person, that isn’t a smart display; it’s an iPad or an iPhone. The good news is that HomeView has multi-user support, and the ad shows it happily switching between users at the drop of a hat. It doesn’t have Face ID, but it does have facial recognition and uses your iPhone to understand whether you’re nearby or not.
Unfortunately, from what I saw yesterday and some of the reviews I’ve seen, it simply doesn’t work. The ad shows someone reading an iMessage and then just walking away, safe in the knowledge that nobody else can read it. Someone tries, but HomeView knows it’s the wrong person, so they’re locked out.
It’s a basic scenario, and one that I expect to happen a lot in homes with a HomeView. It’s also a scenario I’ve seen fail, repeatedly, leaving private messages and other data freely available to anyone who walks by. That’s less secure than an iPad with a passcode. And it breaks the whole premise of HomeView.
This may be something that can be addressed in future software updates, and I hope to be able to test a HomeView in my home with my family to see how it fares. But you can’t buy something on the basis of hoping it gets better with updates. And even ignoring HomeView’s other issues — Siri AI, the way it shows iPhone widgets that it can’t use — the user-switching situation alone is enough to give me pause. And that’s not what I expected after watching Apple’s ad.
Apple iPhone Duo
As I write this, I’ve been using an iPhone Duo full-time for a day shy of two weeks. It’s the Star White one, in case you were wondering, with 512GB of storage. More than enough for my needs. That’s a $/£2,199 foldable smartphone.
I’ll be writing my full month review for AppleInsider, so, again, I won’t get into too many details here. Consider this a teaser, if you will. A taste of what’s to come.
That taste comes in the form of what, for now at least, will be the headline for that review. It’ll set the tone without giving the game away, although perhaps only just.
iPhone Duo 1-month review: Apple got it wrong
You might think that gives the game away, but it doesn’t quite. Because I’ll also say this: The iPhone Duo is the most fun I’ve had with an iPhone since I got my very first Pro Max model. Before that, it was 2017’s iPhone X.
Contradictory? You bet. Consider yourself teased.
“Reviews” and access
Finally, a word on something I’ve seen bubble up across social media in the wake of positive iPhone Duo reviews. Following the news that some handsets were experiencing broken displays due to what appears to be a faulty hinge, I saw some bullish reviewers being nothing short of abused online. It was as if they wanted reviewers to say the iPhone Duo was a terrible device because some failed. That is, as should be obvious, ridiculous.
But it did also raise the question of access. It was suggested that some reviewers refrained from saying anything bad as a way to maintain access to Apple and its products. This is a tale as old as time, and it will remain long after everyone forgets about the failed iPhone Duo units.
The only person I can speak for is myself. I haven’t always received review units from Apple, and before I did, I was very much in the camp that reviewers should review what’s in front of them. That’s the job. It’s why people read reviews.
Now that I’m lucky enough to receive review units, that’s a position that I continue to hold. I’d like to think that my body of work makes it clear that I say what I think, and not always what companies would like to hear.
But I will also say this. If your favorite reviewer is fawning over a product before it’s even out of the bag, take note. If they’re a little too excited about a product, take note. And if they never, ever say anything negative about the product in front of them, take an even bigger note of that as well.
And for the love of your chosen god, don’t base your buying decision on their “review.”
🎮️ Playing: Silent Hill: Townfall
Having never actually played a Silent Hill game for any real length of time, I addressed that terrible mistake in style recently. My wife and I have been playing through Silent Hill: Townfall on the PS5. We finished it in around 14 hours, which I gather is almost exactly the average performance. Then we watched someone speedrun the thing in an hour on YouTube. But to be fair to us, their New Game+ run included some tools we didn’t have, and they glitched through locked doors. So, you know.
The game reviewed fairly well, achieving a score of 80 across 146 reviews on Opencritic. But I do know that some people whose podcasts I listen to were less than complimentary about some of its mechanics.
What I also know is that the game has been extensively patched since those reviews were written and podcasts were recorded and, by all accounts, many improvements were made. If reports of overly-smart enemies and never-ending hiding have put you off trying it, I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised if you do.
✍️ Writing: The jury is out on touchy Macs
One of Apple’s latest releases is the unwieldy-named MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR Display. Or PROLED MacBook Pro, to its friends.
Sitting atop the existing MacBook Pro lineup, it brings touchscreen capabilities and a slight redesign that makes it considerably lighter than the other models. It’s available in 14- and 16-inch configurations, and importantly, uses the exact same M5 Pro and M5 Max chips as the non-PROLED models.
It’s also hugely expensive. And, for me and my AppleInsider piece, the jury is still very much out on who this thing is actually for.
🖥️ Using: Tripod — Podcast Player
I listen to a lot of podcasts, and I’m a long-time Overcast user. I know some people swear by the Apple Podcasts app, but those people are wrong. And that’s especially so now that Tripod is here.

Image: Ben Rice McCarthy
The name, I’m told, is because Tripod is all about triaging podcasts. And the idea is simple: if you subscribe to a lot of podcasts, it’s easy to be overwhelmed by episodes you don’t want to listen to. Or perhaps, you don’t want to listen to them just yet.
Tripod deals with this by putting all new episodes into an inbox from which you triage them, moving episodes into your queue ready to be played. You can also mark entire podcasts to automatically appear in your queue if you like, which I suspect is how a lot of podcasts will be treated.
But none of that is why Tripod has replaced Overcast on my Home Screen. That’s all down to a feature that I’ve yet to see elsewhere. And it’s a game-changer.
Podcasts have, for years, supported chapters. They’re a great way to skip sections of episodes that you don’t want to hear, like spoilers. But they are also brilliant for quick access to portions of episodes that you do want to hear. Unfortunately, not all podcasters take the time to add chapters, and I shake my fist every time I listen to one. It’s user-hostile, at this point, and I’ll never understand it.
Thankfully, Tripod now saves podcasters from my vengeance by automatically adding chapters to episodes that don’t already have them. It uses the show’s transcription to work out what the chapters should be and where they should start and end. It’s been incredibly accurate in my testing over the last couple of weeks. Tripod is worth trying out for that feature alone, but there’s a lot more to like as well.
You can take Tripod and its awesome chapter-creating features for a spin for free for a week. After that, it’s a $2.99 a month subscription. Alternatively, you can pay $19.99 for the year.
Tripod is available for download via the App Store now.
🏁 The wrap-up
This is already a long issue, so I’m going to leave it there. Remember to keep an eye out for my iPhone Duo one-month review in a couple of weeks, and I’ll also report back with any future HomeView thoughts and experiences as I have them. I’m hopeful that the software will catch up with the undoubtedly cool hardware there, but time will tell.
For now, though, it’s time to listen to more podcasts and play the next game on the list: Silver Pines!
Until next time!
👋🏻

Reply